Showing posts with label literacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label literacy. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 23, 2024

(AI) Machine Scoring isn't the Problem: We are ALL Writing for Bots

I've been meaning to write about this for a while. But by now, many people have seen the scores and papers on STAAR exams. Very few essays have needed rescoring. Everything is going to be ok for both content scoring and mechanics. The scoring machine isn't the problem. Instructional relevance is. 

Yes - there are many things we still don't know about the language models used and how machine scoring actually works. That IS a problem but one of transparency from the agency, not for instructional implications.  

So let's think about how we can USE scoring realities to help make the process meaningful to those we serve. Here are five points that explain why we directly teach why machine scoring is relevant to daily life:  

1. All social media works with algorithms. You want to be seen and heard? You use terms and structures that the algorithm values. The scoring machine is looking for key terms from the text and prompt. 

2. Things like Netflix and Youtube give you content based on your behaviors. What you do changes what you are presented. You want to understand how to do the same for readers - even machines? Learn how to respond to reader needs with your text. 

3. Search engines work on what is promoted and searched and clicked frequently. Want a high score? Write what the rubric promotes and seeks. Want a high score? Use what's in the source text that fits the prompt. Scoring works like a giant Family Feud. Other students have already responded to this prompt with the source text and answer. The scoring machine "surveyed" a BUNCH of student essays and knows what most writers said and how the people scored their responses. Comprehend the text and the prompt. Use the text stuff in the written response, summarize how it fits into the text, and say in original thoughts about the connection to the ideas in the prompt. 

4. Search engines use key words to scan content and then matches those terms relevant to user's search terms. Want to be "seen" by the engine? Use terms that match what people want to see. For example, I've been writing for Sirius Education Solutions about thinking and reasoning in a project called Page to Pixel. There's a guy who reads over my stuff, restructures WHERE certain terms appear in the text, adds terms throughout, and chooses special search terms to embed in the code. I have no idea how the code works, but I can see that the key stuff goes in the intro, key connections to the topic are spread in each portion of the headings and body text, and the key stuff also goes into the conclusion. Sound familiar? We trace meaning and coherence through word choice and how we connect our topics through organizational structure. So, want a high score? Use key terms from the prompt and text in the intro and conclusion. Thread those ideas through each body paragraph with text that shares the same ideas/synonyms/textual context. The guy who edits my work for this puts these terms in bold so I can see how they thread through the text. I can see the connection and repetition of concepts through the entire text. 

5. Companies use machine scoring to preview resumes, cover letters, and communications. Priorities are given to text that includes what the company is looking for in the match of personnel to the job description and company goals. Understanding machine scoring is intensely personal and relevant to all those who are seeking employment. 

Machine scoring isn't new. Digital evaluation going on in the background of almost everything we do and see. And teaching without including explicit lessons on the relevance of these scoring machines isn't in the TEKS, but we'd be remiss if we didn't address the reality directly. 


Thursday, May 12, 2022

Unpacking ELAR Assessed Curriculum for Ease of Use

     My friends and I have been working on solutions for unpacking standards and writing curriculum documents. As Sherella and I talked, be bemoaned the spaghetti reality that is ELAR. We asked these questions: 

  • How do we put all of this together in a way that is easy to look at and understand what we are supposed to teach? 
  • How do we show that comprehension involves author's purpose and craft + text structures + text characteristics + uses of language + metacognitive skills all at the same time? 
  • How do we cluster the standards in such a way that teacher realize that a lesson about point of view (7.9E) that gives the definitions of subjective and objective point of view isn't really what we are teaching nor how it will be used in life or assessment? 
  • How do we help new teachers or untrained folks with the content and the pedagogy? 
  • How do we unpack this stuff that results in something we can use to plan better lessons? 
  • How do we unpack this stuff that we can use with kids? 
    How can we unpack this stuff in a way that doesn't take 40 million years to complete and hundreds of pages to print? 
     Being the geek I am, I used constant comparative analysis and axial coding to reveal themes and connections. Coding with color font and highlighted cells revealed how each Standard (Knowledge and Skills + Student Expectation) houses overlapping Strands and Assessment Reporting Categories. 

    Here's an example: Most teachers look at what they are supposed to teach and see: 

7.9E: identify the use of literary devices, including subjective and objective point of view.

     Teachers then plan a lesson where students look at texts and explain which ones are written with a subjective point of view and which are written with an objective point of view. Pardon the pun, but that's not the point. 

     Here's the "formula": [Author's Purpose and Craft (Strand) + "influence meaning" (purpose) + "communicate meaning" (comprehension) + literary devices: point of view (language)] * "applies" author's craft "to develop his or her own products and performances"

     Here's the color coding key I used for the research:
Genre Characteristics
Literary Elements
Literary Genres
Nonfiction
Argument
Comprehension
Text Structure
Characteristics/Language
Metacognitive Skills

     In other words, the "point" is to help learners with two tasks (as opposed to two pieces of knowledge) and multiple strands (as opposed to one TEK). Here's what we unpacked to craft guiding questions that address content + skills + genre + rigor + assessed curriculum. 

With literary texts, how does the author influence and communicate meaning through choices of point of view, including subjective and objective point of view? What does the point of view reveal or hide? (Example: Because the story is told by the friends, we see how their reactions are different than the main character. Antaeus English I 2019 STAAR). 

As a writer of literary texts, how do I influence and communicate meaning through choices of point of view including, subjective and objective point of view? What does the point of view reveal or hide? (Example: What point of view is best to show an unreliable narrator in the story I am writing? In what ways do I used language and character development to make that happen?) 

     We started with Author's Purpose and Craft because that's where all reading and writing begins. And that's how readers first experience texts (Rosenblatt). We loaded all the standards afterward as if they are connected to the heart of Author's Purpose and Craft. 

     Cheryl, Sherella, and I are going to be talking about this more. Would you like to join the conversation? Here's the mock-up drafts of our thinking: 

7th Grade Curriculum Unpacked (Writing) Note: Assessed Curriculum for writing has not yet been released.



Tuesday, July 13, 2021

Your Lesson Ain't Goin to Heaven or Hollywood: Overcoming Create and Delete

For a while, I was not able to write about what I was learning in education. There were rumors and fears that I was writing about teachers I served. When I did write about teachers I served, I used their names. Yet, perception is a beast y'all. While I never, ever wrote ugly things about people and their mistakes, the censorship happened. For a while, I played around with a pseudonym. Ela R. Goodnight good speak for me in anonymity. I even bought a fake wig and some funky glasses to compliment her 1980's wardrobe that for some reason is still in my closet from when I started teaching. Yet, it never seemed right to put the words out there. 

Until today. 

Heather, Bria, Zack, Sam, and I were talking about how we help teachers with their lessons in a way that would free up some time and provide mentorship models of effective instruction. It reminded me of what ole Ela had to say back in the early days of the pandemic. 

A friend (Bettye) stopped by for lunch. On the way to The Burrow in Claude  (I was craving one of their pulled pork omelettes) she berated herself for the difficulty she is having in completing her online blended learning course. "Claire, my teaching partner,  just busted through all the assignments, but I want mine to be really good. And they just aren't. And it's taking me forever." 

"Honey," I replied over the top of my dollar store shades. "Don't you know your lessons aren't goin' to heaven? Heck, they aren't even going to town." She looked at me funny, but I am funny lookin'. 

Consume, Critique, Produce

My friend was missing a very important point here related to Dr. John O'Flavahaven's work at the University of Maryland. O'Flavahaven's Consume, Critique, Produce model is very effective when we look at how we design lessons that give mentor texts and examples of the products we wish for kids to produce or processes they can emulate. But the way my friend was thinking about it was kinda like putting a saddle on a cow. Or lipstick on a pig. You can, but why?

True. We consume a lot of media. Professionally produced, curated, airbrushed stuff of virtual confection and perfection. Yet: Why would we ever expect that perfection from ourselves and our lessons? Why, that's not even the purpose of our lessons. Just like nobody actually looks like those cover models, nobody's lessons look like Dead Poets Society. (Nor Bad Teacher either, just sayin'.) 

Creating virtual opportunities and lessons for kids really isn't about creating perfect, curated videos that could win Emmy Awards. Teachers don't need to be worried about delivering their 30 second acceptance speeches before the music swells and they are escorted offstage. Face to face, online, or blended mixes of all of it aren't about the fake, yet polished nature of media. Teaching is about your moment with a child that moves their thinking and knowing to a new place of participation and contribution. 

Overcoming Create and Delete

Here's some thoughts to reframe what you are doing with virtual learning and stop yourself from perseverating over the create and delete cycle.  

1. If you were teaching a lesson face to face, you'd have to reread, rephrase, and repeat words when they don't come out right. You'd walk over to where you thought you left that stack of papers and forget that you laid them on a kid's desk. Someone would inevitably interrupt the class with an announcement about who needed to come check out in the office. You'd make a mistake or some kid would do something you didn't expect or want. (Like the time Johnny picked his nose and wiped it on the inside of his turtleneck sweater.) There is no way to press delete and start the whole class over. Nor would you. You'd just monitor, adjust, and move on. You are a human in the live, sometimes unscripted (although carefully planned) impromptu of arena of classroom instruction. 

When you are making a recording, monitor, adjust, and move on. Click save and upload that sucker. Ain't  nobody got time for 15 retakes before yearbook, cheer practice, and bus duty. 

2. For some reason, people seem to think that video is going to be useful next year. I have horrifying memories of playing videos recorded in the late 60's and early 70's for my 90's babies. They couldn't get past the polyester prints and beehives to focus on the content. They were making fun of the setting and context rather than learning. 

Furthermore, our pedagogy and content need updating and refining as much as our wardrobe. When you teach the lesson next year - even if you are recording it - hopefully you have learned a thing or two since then. Hopefully, you've realized some stuff you need to address because of who your kids are this year. Put that old video in an archive for posterity and move on with what this class needs this year. Besides, you probably have a new haircut, glasses, and a few more wrinkles since then. Move on and re-record.

3. Point two connects me to another idea. My poor other made the mistake of asking me whether or not after 30 years I was gonna get this teaching stuff figured out and stop staying late at school lugging that canvas bag home. Like, when was I going to stop re-creating the wheel. Incredibly, he was still breathing and able to remark: "You'd think by now that someone  would have made a program where the kids could just go online and do the work." 

There will NEVER be a script or video or a program that is good enough to cover the complexities and nuances of teaching humans year after year. Teaching is a reactive and interactive science that requires the decision making art of a well-prepared, sophisticated, and compassionate teacher. Especially when the teaching goes virtual.

Heaven Bound

Bettye, none of your lessons belong in Hollywood. But the effort, heart, and messy humanity behind it is the only school thing headed for heaven.

Hugs, Pitti-Pats, and Arpeggios of Laughter, 

Ela R. Goodnight

Tuesday, July 6, 2021

Writing Like an Insider: Identifying as a Scholar

This morning, Dr. Lesley addressed the Llano Estacado Writing Alliance about Joining a Discourse Community as a Scholarly Writer. While that floats my boat personally, her ideas made me think about the writers I will encounter in the fall. Here are some ideas that I want to preserve and communicate. 

  • Teachers of writing should write. I will be finding my voice as a writer. This will feed my instruction and support for students and teachers. 
  • Writing Fluency is more complex than reading fluency. (Lesley, 2021 presentation)

 Hmmm. Here's the definition that Dr. Lesley shared with us:

Writing Fluency: The ability to produce written language rapidly, appropriately, cognitively, and coherently (Latif, 2013)

Students need to become aware of the components of their writing fluency. Our instructional activities should be explicit about the goals and the ways in which we achieve writing fluency. We want our students to begin writing after diffusing the prompt or assignment, not from a disjointed stream of consciousness, but from a capacity that considers deep meaning and the genre characteristics and conventions that will accurately and effectively deliver the message to their audience. They need to know how to get that kind of writing fluency going automatically. 

  • Each writing even it a unique rhetorical event (Lesley, 2021 presentation).  

That's why it feels like you are starting over each time. That's why there is no formula. The rhetorical situation will always be different. Do we let kids know that this is true for everyone and every writing task? Do they know the struggle is normal and they are not alone? 

  • Writing is inquiry (Lesley, 2021 presentation).  

YAAAAS. It is always new. We are always rethinking and rewriting - learning all the while. Writing is thinking made visible in ink, graphite, or binary code. 

  • We learn to write and investigate our thinking through writing (Lesley, 2021 presentation).

How do you learn to do something? You get in there and do it. You learn about the something and a lot more about yourself. 

  •  Scholarly Voice: scholarly voice is about contextualizing the research, situating the study and the researcher personally (Lesley, 2021 presentation). 

We write so they can see our face and hear our voice and know our personality. The way we write exposes our thinking and our personality. Do the kids know it doesn't have to be stilted or boring? 

  • Introspective writing helps students move into a creative space where they are free to play with language, capture descriptive details, elaborate on the seemingly insignificant and juxtapose disparate ideas against each other. Introspection allows the writer's self to be present in all facets of the writing act (Lesley, in press). 

Wow. That's writing like an insider. So here's my questions to guide instruction in the fall. 

1. How do we help kids write like an insider for particular genres if we don't teach them how to read a text for how it is structured and the techniques the writer is using? How do we teach them to dissect a text not just for comprehension, but for CREATION for their own purposes? I need to create lessons and opportunities for this work...to go beyond comprehension to CRAFT. Our Texas ELAR standards have two Knowledge and Skills statements for craft. One is to analyze craft. The other is to USE craft for their own meaningful products and performances. 

2. How do we help kids write like an insider if they never read the kind of stuff we are asking them to write? We need more mentor texts that kids have written. 



New Spin on Blueprinting: Plotting the Future at Walkon's

 Three Teachers Talk recently wrote about the architectural approach to prewriting at a tried and "still" true method. Honestly, since I first experienced it in the Abydos Writing Institute, it is the best method to collect and store memories that can be used for writing of all genres, not just the introspective. 

Then I went to Walkon's Sports Bistreaux. Being a food snob, I had shunned the place, shuddering at the thought of poorly prepared bar food. But the Boudin Balls were a welcome surprise. But... as we were seated, the waitress set down these napkins: 



And she told us the story of how Brandon and Jack sketched out their dream as their team flew home after playing at the University of Tennessee. They blueprinted their dream, y'all. And the other side of the napkin was an invitation to prewrite...to plan something new...to dream and sketch the plan. 

Cheers to you and your dreams. I'm headed back to Walkons for another serving of those fried rice and pork balls. You think they will give me a package of those napkins to use with the kids? 

Cheers to you and your dreams. 



Saturday, July 3, 2021

Deliberate, Effortful Strategies under Conscious Control become Skills under Automatic Control

Judy Wallis: And what we hope is these deliberate, effortful strategies under conscious control become skills under automatic control. 

 I'm always honored when Judy Wallis reads and considers my efforts. She always seems to dive into the basis and research underneath what I'm experiencing. And when she references an article, I know that it is something worth serious consideration. 

My friend Bama Coward used to say: A strategy is not something you do with a pencil. As usual, Judy has the research at her fingertips. Clarifying Differences Between Reading Skills and Reading Strategies is a must read for practitioners of critical and transformative ELAR pedagogy. Afflerback, Pearson, and Paris nail important considerations about how we initially teach and what our goals are for helping kids internalize and use those strategies in ways that become automatic skills in their comprehension and composing processes. Where are my kids on the continuum of strategies and skilled reading? 

Tuesday, October 27, 2020

Progression of Success Criteria for (STAAR) Informative Writing

Kendall Wright, Jamie Brigman, and I were working on assessment capable learners (Fisher, Hattie, Frey, ) . After a baseline writing prompt and a comparison of sample essays, Kendall wanted students to be able to determine where their essay fit in the progression of papers and to evaluate where they were in their own progression of learning. After doing so, she wanted students to be able to set goals. 

Yet, she felt that leaving them open to crafting their own goals might be too vague and might drift from the unit goals and expectations. We brainstormed some statements, organized them into a progression, and then created this document as a resource. (Kendall will be using the blog post referenced here as her lesson progression and approach to the writing assessment.) 

The draft of the document we created is below: 

Progression of Success Criteria for Informative Writing

 

Tuesday, June 9, 2020

Rules or Tools of Grammar

I just found the most wonderful example of how Jeff Anderson's Patterns of Power can illuminate how we apply Author's Purpose and Craft to Grammar. Tara Salmon, from Highland Park, and I have composed this lesson exemplar for you as an exemplar for the Region 16 Grammar Geeks course.

I know Jeff...and he would always agree that grammar is about how we craft language to impact the reader. Our standards require us to go beyond the grammatical structures and rules to explore how they help us as readers and writers. 

If you are skimming the article - look for when I change the font.

The lesson below is an exemplar of how grammar is connected to how we read and write with craft and purpose. 

Standard: Complex sentences with subject-verb agreement and avoidance of splices, run-ons, and fragments. (Composition, Editing: Grades 6-12, Di)

Focus Phrase: I will write complex sentences using correct punctuation and subject-verb agreement. 

Invitation to Notice: Because he was small, Stuart was often hard to find around the house. Stuart Little, E. B. White


To Consider:   
  • Rule: When the AAAWWUBBIS comes at the beginning of a sentence, a comma follows. If the AAAWWUBBIS comes in the middle of a sentence, there is no comma needed. 
  • Craft: What is the impact on meaning and prosody when those structures are used? How is the author using those structures to develop the character, advance the plot, or express theme?

Invitation to Compare and Contrast:  
  • Because he was so small, Stuart was often hard to find around the house.
  • Stuart was often hard to find around the house because he was so small.
  • Note the grammatical differences between the two sentences. Note when a comma is needed and when it is not.
  • Note the impact each has on you as a reader. What changes in terms of the writer's emphasis? What changes in your visualizations and comprehension?

Invitation to Edit:  Compose the sentence in both ways and analyze the effect on character, theme, and meaning.
  • When his best friend disappears from her nest Stuart is determined to track her down.
  • Stuart is a lover of adventure although he's shy.
  • Since he lives in New York Stuart is used to city life. 

Reflection: What did we learn about writing from this author? What changed? Name the effect of the change you wish students to consider.

What is the IMPACT of using the dependent clause first? What is the IMPACT if the independent clause is used first? For the example here, I would say that the author's purpose is to emphasize how SMALL Stuart is. The main point is not that he is hard to find - that's just an example. The main point - and emphasized throughout the book is that he is SMALL. This is important to establish his character traits when he is introduced because it is a huge contrast to the optimism he marshals despite the huge deck stacked against him. I guess what I'm saying is that we have to go beyond grammatical structures and rules to express how they give us vehicles for power and beauty in discerning the author's message and the ability to craft our own contributions.

Teacher's Application to Writing: Here's how I'm using it today: "Because I was already irritated before entering the building, I continued to find it difficult to focus throughout the rest of the day." I'm liking this better than the other way around: I continued to find it difficult to focus throughout the rest of the day because I was already irritated before entering the building. The second version makes it seem like the point was the difficulty in focusing instead of the CAUSE. It also delays the emotion until the ending of the sentence. I want my reader to feel my irritation way before the end of that sentence.

Tuesday, January 8, 2019

Fixing Fluency Practice

Seeing Past the End of My Nose


Many teachers have kids practice with fluency passages and folders. Repeated reading helps kids increase their reading rates. Read too slow and comprehension suffers. On the flip side, reading too fast can do the same thing.

Something is missing here. Like most things, we stop too short with our instructional practices. We make student activities about doing stuff instead of doing stuff because there is a reason to do so. Fluency is no different. (Ask the kids: Why are we doing fluency practice?) And since fluency is now in our ELAR TEKS all the way up into 8th grade, we'd better get ahead of this before we institute classroom practices and routines (and add more tests) that do harm in the name of standards and assessment.

If we have kids practicing fluency passages and graphing their improvements with repeated readings - and that's all we are doing with it - we are teaching rote skills without meaning. Kind of like writing your spelling test words three times each in different colors. Might as well memorize a random list of phone numbers. It's a waste of time.

Experience It:

Read this article called Bad Dancers and time yourself. Give it your best shot with fluent expression and prosody.

This passage has about 319 words. After 8th grade, reading this passage aloud should take a little less than two minutes to read aloud. How'd you do?


Fluency is a TOOL


Fluency is not just about how fast, how expressive, and how accurately you decode and phrase text. Instead, fluency is a TOOL that good readers use to help them make sense of text and monitor their comprehension. 

Yes, fluency includes: rate, accuracy, expression, phrasing/prosody. But readers USE those four things for adjusting the reading performance: adjusting for purpose and genre, adjusting for decoding and comprehension, adjusting for silent, oral, or performance purposes that include the audience and the delivery of the message. But I think most classroom models for fluency only focus on the first four. If so, we divorce student from how fluency helps us make and communicate meaning. Fluency instruction must include a focus on making meaning, meatcognition, and conscious choices about what good reading requires. If we don't focus on fluency as a tool, then we make reading a mindless think about calling words correctly and quickly. Instead, we make reading about finishing.  Fluency is supposed to be about understanding and using text for our purposes as readers and thinkers and doers. 


Something is Rotten in the State of Denmark: 

Let's go back to the passage I had you read about Bad Dancers. How we go about reading and approaching a text depends on the GENRE. Teachers tell me, "Oh, we do that. When they get their fluency passage, we tell them that it is expository or narrative." Really? How many times to you open an email and people start off telling you that they are writing to persuade you? How many times to the newspaper headlines and magazines start off by telling you that the text is expository? Never. You have to figure that out for yourself. At least you should. 

Sure, we need to do some explicit modeling with kids and teach them how a good reader goes about diffusing and reading against specific features in each genre. But at some point, kids need to be able to figure that out for themselves and decide how that needs to impact their reading, fluency rate, and comprehension. Fluency passages are the perfect place to practice those skills. 

Fear of Impending Doom

Check out this set of bookmarks from Lead4Ward for elementary and secondary. Which of the genre bookmarks fit Bad Dancers? 

When I discussed this with a group of teachers, they pulled out three different cards: Literary Nonfiction, Expository, and Persuasive. It was quite a discussion that had us re-entering and re-reading the text purposefully to determine which genre fit the best. Get this straight y'all. We were not merely passing our eyes over the text with the goal of reading it faster and without any decoding mistakes. We had a real reason to reread. Having kids reread stuff for no discernible purpose will NOT achieve our Literacy objectives. They might read faster, but they'll be bored as hell and no thinking will be involved. We're not in the robot business, y'all, yinz, you-uns, you guys, youse guys -  regardless of the region you hail from. From which you hail. Whatever. 

First of all, we realized that we read Bad Dancers the first time as if it were a narrative or literary nonfiction. Which means we really didn't "get" what the author wanted us to understand. As we looked for evidence in the text to justify our decisions, we realized the text didn't match our purpose or approach to reading it! 

We zoned in on the Expository bookmark. (Might I mention that we won't be using that silly term in the new ELAR Standards? We'll call it Informational like the rest of the civilized world.) Soon, we realized that there were some nuanced features of persuasion that didn't match the formulaic way we teach kids to write persuasion with the thesis blatantly posed at the end of the first paragraph. (Bad Dancers isn't five-paragraph-blathering-nonsense either.) 

It started to get scary...
...as we realized that the author had a clear perspective and bias about dancing
...as we realized that the author laid out a clear path of logic and reasoning
...as we made discerning distinctions about her opinions and facts
...as we juxtaposed the feasibility of accepting her ideas into our own lives

As we realized these things, we heard ominous music.  What if the topic had been less innocuous and more insidious? Our approach to reading the text would have left our minds open to manipulation at worst and at risk for incorrectly answering multiple choice questions at the least. 

I am stunned again by the moral imperative of our work and service as literacy professionals. We must go further than teaching kids to practice fluency as a rote and isolated skill divorced from meaning and thinking. 

Probably preaching to the choir. So what can we do to beef up our fluency passage work? Because I'm not asking you to stop fluency like I am asking you to stop with the Spelling-Test-on-Friday nonsense. 

As Plain as the Nose on my Face

The genre places demands on our fluency. When the teachers and I read the text again, we used the genre bookmarks to help us ask questions about the text to guide our more critical purposes for reading the second time. We realized...
....a need to make a decision about what we believe about bad dancers. Are there bad dancers in the world or not? 
....a need to see if this idea is feasible: In the way we see and live life, do we realistically see the truth in the author's perspective? What would this idea add or take away from our life choices? 
...a need to trace the author's path of logic and reasoning purposefully laid out for us. How is the author presenting the ideas? Are there any red flags (logical fallacies) that we should note? 
...a need to see the author's perspectives, facts, opinions, and biases. Do we know the differences between those things? Which facts warrant further research to verify? What hidden biases and motives might be driving the author to communicate these points? How do I respond emotionally and intellectually to these assertions? 

Don't we want students to read like that? 

When Throwing a Monkey Wrench into the Fray is a Good Thing

Fluency practice isn't necessarily a bad thing. But we definitely need to throw a monkey wrench into what most of us are doing with fluency practice. We need to interrupt the mindlessness. Here's a suggestion for a more literate, principled approach. 

  1. Have students read the fluency passage appropriate for their independent reading level to their reading partner. Have the partner time the reading. Perhaps you could even use the Synth App to record, share, and respond to each other. Consider graphing the first rate if that really matters. I'm starting to wonder if graphing the speed/rate is sending the wrong message about why we do this work.  
  2. Students then pull out the genre bookmarks to discuss and decide which genre the text best fits. They should highlight text features and evidence to justify their decisions. (If you want to have a quick check for students working independently, write the genre on the back of the passage. They can self-check and adjust before moving on to the next step. 
  3. The Lead4Ward genre bookmarks list the demands each genre places on the astute reader. We can use those demand to guide our purposes for reading! Students discuss those purposes and turn them into questions to guide their reading. (You can use the ones we composed from Bad Dancers listed in the previous section.)
  4. Student reread the text again, using their questions to guide their purpose for reading. Students time the reading and chart the results. They should change their rate at times to make sure they are attending to sections of the text that warrant closer inspection. (Of course, this will have to be modeled during Read Alouds and Shared Reading time in the Reading Workshop block.) Students can discuss the questions and ideas with their reading partners.
  5.  Students conduct a third re-reading to practice the basic elements of fluency (the first four) and to bump up their reading rates up to grade level expectations. They can chart and compare the results over the three readings. Or you can throw those out the window and let the kids create a Reader's Theatre, Choral Reading, or Dramatic Reading of the text. You might even have the kids complete the final reading at the guided reading table to offer final support and feedback for where they could head next or to resolve problems that remain.  
  6. With their partners or during the whole class debrief at the end of Reading Workshop, discuss the experience. In your second reading, what adjustments did you make? Why? What impact did that have about your understanding and reasoning about the text? 

Additional Resources: 

Some more resources: 
Fluency Handouts from the TEA Reading to Learn Academy: These handouts show you the following things:
  • How to set up fluency folders with graphs and handouts
  • How to set goals for fluency
  • How to add a comprehension element to fluency practice











Tuesday, October 30, 2018

Writing is supposed to DO something to the reader...Feedback Protocols

When you write something, it's supposed to DO something to a reader/audience. Giving students authentic opportunities to test their ideas on real readers just makes sense. It blends reading and writing. It involves everyone in literary analysis and critical thinking. It gives writers a reason and focus for revision. 

Joyce Armstrong Carroll and Edward E. Wilson shared powerful grouping strategies to structure how we can create communities of writers in our classrooms (2007, p. 67-89). I started collecting these feedback strategies and groupings in my digital portfolio.

Over time, I've collected other strategies for the collection. This week, I am working in The AP Vertical Teams Guide for English (2002) to create a session on the penultimate chapter of this incredible resource.

I've adapted three of the strategies as feedback protocols and included them here for you:

PAMDISS
The Four Bases of Effective Writing
Peer Evaluation: Hitting the Target

Armstrong-Carroll, J. & Wilson, E. E. (2007). ACTS of teaching: How to teach writing. Heinemann, Portsmouth, NH.

The College Board. (2002). The AP Vertical Teams Guide for English, 2nd Ed. College Entrance Examination Board.

Wednesday, May 23, 2018

New TEKS Overview: Interconnected Strands

Monday and Tuesday, I worked with a dedicated group of teachers and leaders at Childress ISD. Yes. These teachers came for staff development on the last week of school. Why? Because they want time to think about and plan their curriculum and textbook selection processes. Brilliant.

As we worked through the documents, I came away with a deeper understanding of the design and interconnectedness of the standards - even though I have been working with variations of the document for several years now. 

Here are two videos that describe my new learning. Thank you to Victoria Young and Jennifer Wilkerson who led CREST (Coalition of Reading and English Supervisors of Texas) in understanding the structure of the TEKS and how we can go about reading them to begin our curriculum planning.

Video One: TEKS Strands and Substrands


Video Two: Interconnectedness Across Strands within a grade level.